CompletetheMap IV

honestly the table is not very.:pensive: As in the previous competition, the camera dash wins. It makes no difference how long you went UKM, you can ride and shoot a video and you are a winner.

So why the mapillary sequence
yDwD-N6MTspSR61LozswHg
is not “green” in the grid??

Hi eneerhut,

As you know one user can make pictures from two/three/four cameras at the same time from one point in the car to different views. Then he can manually/automatically move one from GPS tracks to neibours pedestrian segments. In this case he has double of UKM and double of pictures (one from main road and second from pedestrian). This is bug of counting which there now in the system and all see it on the map.
I suggest divide results of users which use more then one device at the same time by two/three/four (depends from quantyty of cameras he use) or delete the sequences which connected to the wrong roads.

That’s not true actually. The optimal interval for images is 5 images per second, but beyond that there is no advantage. This interval has been chosen as it allows us to derive as much map data as possible from each image and create better 3D reconstructions.

Only unique sequences are receiving points, so again a dashcam would need to be travelling on the right roads to generate a score.

@Sapozhnik this is an unfortunate outcome of inaccurate GPS tracks, but I am not away of anyone abusing this deliberately. It would be a very manual and time consuming process to do so. If you can point to an example of this we can consider options.

Also, multiple camera angles should be encouraged, not discouraged.

But they aren’t, currently, with this point system…

That’s true and something we’re keen to fix, but we don’t want to actively discourage people using four cameras either.

The main addition needed here is for the map matching of each sequence to factor in bearing.

@eneerhut

Could you please send me any test email and I forward you examples of incorrect counting. sapozhnik@gmail.com

I agree but also in this case you should encourage owners of 360 cameras. For exapmle, multiply his results to 360. They have less speed, less quantities pictures but more productivity

Agree. Will work on 360º and multi-cam in next iteration of scoring system.

Regarding the examples, I’m interested in examples of deliberately manipulating GPS tracks. There is not much we can do about inaccurate GPS for the time being.

@eneerhut

When will you make “Kyiv Central” zone?
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-4

1 Like

I’m curious since I’m not familiar with these things. Wouldn’t the optimal interval be distance based? So when you’re speaking 5 seconds, at what rate of travel? Is that walking? Thank you.

1 Like

I am happy to hear that.
It is also the first time I hear that.
I was afraid that two times a second was too expensive.
But on foot I do one per second, unless Mapillary does not mind the double cost for little extra value.
example :

2 Likes

BTW - Thanks for getting this all set up. I’m using it for a trial to see how it works. When is the next one? I’d like to ping some places in town to see if a few folks would be interested. For example, the University of North Florida offers GIS courses. Seems like this would be a good excuse to focus on their wonderful little campus and get it all mapped.

1 Like

@eneerhut
and
support@mapillary.com - request (6628)

When will you make “Boyarka” (Ukraine) zone?
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/boyarka


UPDATE
fix = TRUE

===== !!! IMAGES ONLY 2017…2018 YEAR !!! =====
===== cheater or bug ??? =====
go to
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/global-challenge/q1-2019/

see
kaartcam (Mapillary)
ukm=46 img=95950 score=223490

user as TOP-5 …


NONE IMAGES in From=2018-12-27 To=2019-01-31

…and

go to statistics…

============= UKRAINE =================

https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/brovary2019-1
kaartcam | 2150 | 1.3 | 894

https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-south/
kaartcam | 1622 | 5.8 | 2438

https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-2/
kaartcam | 4240 | 1.4 | 889

https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-3/
kaartcam | 9400 | 9.2 | 5193

=============== CHINA ====================

https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/hongkong/
kaartcam – 87914 images – 40 km

============== conclusion =====================

@eneerhut

kaartcam: cheater or bug ???

FOR HISTORY
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/global-challenge/q1-2019/

1
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-4/

2
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-1/

3
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-3/

4
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-2/

5
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/hobart/

6
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/irpin/

7
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-5/

8
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/vilareal/

9
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/jacksonville/

10
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kharkiv-1/

11
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kharkiv-2/

12
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/san_maurizio_canavese/

13
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/san_carlo_canavese/

14
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/brovary2019-1/

15
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/melbourne_north/

16
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/uzhgorod-1/

17
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/ivrea/

18
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/boyarka/

19
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/horenychi/

20
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/temecula/

21
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/budapest-2/

22
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/istanbul/

23
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kovyagi/

24
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/ballerup2019-1/

25
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/barnaul/

26
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/kyiv-6/

27
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/guyandotte/

28
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/vigodifassa/

28
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/biella/

30
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/castellon/

31
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/sevastopol/

32
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/valli_di_lanzo/

33
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/la_trinidad-2/

34
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/zusmarshausen/

35
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/hongkong/

36
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/dunkerque/

37
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/stonetown/

38
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/fortaleza/

39
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/hungerford-2/

40
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/leipzig/

41
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/lisboa-2/

42
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/secunderabad/

43
https://mapillary.github.io/mapillary_greenhouse/ctm/uherske_hradiste/


@eneerhut

SCORE JSON

Kyiv West https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.370426357906094,50.38013120258955,30.49730614726178,50.471664443718765&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kyiv East https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.554885766047363,50.41238505877805,30.681970372825813,50.50398466546291&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kyiv Central https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kyiv North https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.409711016028552,50.454280257565756,30.53684153001094,50.545807415978665&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Hong Kong https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=114.14778966271619,22.257564694367,114.22240880940387,22.358135492264687&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Hobart https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=147.27295060526538,-42.9701965016307,147.32042510752854,-42.753134615801116&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Irpin https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.167352894199198,50.485281451063294,30.294438262853053,50.576698130343004&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kyiv South https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.56163144611752,50.3231510398294,30.688445882006466,50.41478039283305&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Vila Real https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-7.81828368926909,41.3035725074994,-7.7336461391514675,41.367154457214745&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Jacksonville https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-81.71058564786996,30.255610754941888,-81.6389810320089,30.338166152246487&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kharkiv https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=36.32312646050244,49.89529814626611,36.45124323505363,49.98895530304769&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kharkiv Southeast https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=36.34123182782226,49.867510552871344,36.46926979490944,49.96118089474171&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
San Maurizio Canavese https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=7.5844578982206725,45.17834845233258,7.677075270617239,45.254905979514426&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
San Carlo Canavese https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=7.562947414754566,45.208824797280286,7.655597839399288,45.285351615680625&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Uzhgorod https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=22.229834926341972,48.57792787324141,22.34572012614849,48.665701673065854&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Ivrea https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=7.828119516512497,45.429000552747056,7.921532126389333,45.50573420948443&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Melbourne North https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=144.93376501289507,-37.807776703863595,145.01424149293618,-37.74419475414825&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Boyarka https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.238866363934214,50.282190799424136,30.36537026827424,50.373698779164606&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Brovary https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.726084304711268,50.465456218971575,30.85342953188391,50.55710958066865&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Temecula https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-117.18205527404842,33.4339032012879,-117.13393123110075,33.61298925657872&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Istanbul https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=28.92399942275836,40.98161621841598,29.026976815625886,41.07574781290954&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Budapest https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=18.98488309696479,47.45505692720438,19.094988411342037,47.540946714511996&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Kovyagi https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=35.48178132833612,49.8572522926844,35.60948296997979,49.95070293889609&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Ballerup https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=12.309093300873412,55.681578416333295,12.43587650178938,55.759939435467345&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Barnaul https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=83.63412852141508,53.324452997071205,83.7443146292769,53.39758596525171&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Guyandotte https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-82.39474715712439,38.3887401192543,-82.31358896936992,38.467456847069236&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Vigo de Fassa https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=11.628532274604801,46.38109634177287,11.728458611182687,46.4612310785947&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Horenychi https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=30.15186922070586,50.36891716990583,30.27858776313478,50.46036238731574&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Biella https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=8.005679653401783,45.50682524856951,8.099466440512774,45.58371634376401&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Castellón https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-0.06800036979799778,39.915248088647544,-0.033220167866279716,40.0640747762434&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Sevastopol https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=33.45057927258125,44.54584027140696,33.56329825163068,44.64046236772159&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Valli di Lanzo https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=7.273554168897212,45.29288270701005,7.336445831105772,45.33710866425465&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
La Trinidad https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=120.54837715959044,16.393916072849294,120.620330453884,16.502020400825497&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Zusmarshausen https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=10.547637368205958,48.360843438676135,10.65076618391346,48.43941460161122&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Dunkerque https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=2.348963972359825,51.01274007822437,2.4469330524882738,51.08221087716818&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Stone Town https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=39.16816711695091,-6.230524507982336,39.22769602537753,-6.09739854483426&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Fortaleza https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-38.55679954635174,-3.845118213290042,-38.49208660165034,-3.7233951275823687&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Hungerford https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-1.3401811544231428,51.30452537724088,-1.3060565488310754,51.498551472228804&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Leipzig https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=12.198255537114344,51.3012362581773,12.311015821000918,51.38054252359286&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Lisboa https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=-9.21915139110476,38.65873754366847,-9.179087311682983,38.825457468361726&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Secunderabad https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=78.51547984177957,17.454609209105726,78.57816701988484,17.54699843971615&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
Uherské Hradiště https://a.mapillary.com/v3/leaderboard/score?client_id=UTZhSnNFdGpxSEFFREUwb01GYzlXZzo5MTUxN2EzZGE2NDY4ODEx&&bbox=17.41573886547938,49.02833994921896,17.52830756831718,49.11258932662318&start_time=2018-12-26T23:00:00.000Z&end_time=2019-01-31T23:59:59.000Z
2 Likes

Photo report on the receipt of the prize for the first place. Thank you all and see you in the new challenges.:wink:
p.s. I promise not to take away the top prizes anymore, probably … :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye: :wink:

2 Likes

That is not a professional smartphone holder.

1 Like

selfie stick nonsense

1 Like

Thanks for the follow-up, @westbam. I hope you have fun with your new toys. We’ll see how things go in the future.